I'd save the puppy. The way A-Rod has been hitting lately he'd probably miss the car anyway.
I'd yell to Alex to save the puppy. Problem solved.
I would yell out to A-rod " Pick up the puppy and run a car is coming at you".
Save A-Rod. A lot less potential legal issues for killing a puppy vs a human.
I would save Rodriguez. He would probably help me pay for college as a result of saving his life.
The puppy. The other one just got lost forever.
The puppy... I have no idea who the dude is.
A car is coming down the street. In the street, there is a stray puppy and Alex Rodriguez. You could only save one. Which one would you save?